Buck Blunder Of The Year Vote


It’s voting time again! Since the season is over, we can now vote on the best Buck Blunder of the year. I have compiled a list of 5 solid Buck Blunders for us to vote on. I will be posting videos from MLB.com if that Buck Blunder was caught on film! So vote to your hearts content and make sure you spread the word to other to vote :)

Jonny Mac Walk Off home run Buck-gasm

On April 23rd, 2011, John MacDonald hit a walk off home run against Adam Russell and the Tampa Bay Rays. Buck Martinez made a weird call and it was awesome! This ball is GONEahhhGONEEEEEE… OUTTAAAA HERE! View the video below:

Bautista Has Tied It Up… Maybe Not

On April 27th, 2011, during the top of the 4th in Texas in a 3-6 Texas lead with runners on 1st and 2nd against Derek Holland, Jose Bautista hit a double to the left center over Nelson Cruz’s head. Two came into score and Buck Martinez said that Bautista has tied it up…. But if you do the math, the Blue Jays are down by 1 run 5-6 :) View the video below:

Abraham Cibia Jumps On The First Pitch…

In the Bronx on May 23rd, 2011, J.P. Arencibia was up to bat against Bartolo Colon in the top of the 6th. He swung on the first pitcher and hit a double to center. The only problem was Buck Martinez called him Abraham Cibia! View the video below:

2 Home Run… 2 Run Homer By Bautista. Number 28.

During a 3-0 game in the top of the 9th vs. Boston on July 5th at Fenway, Jonathan Papelbon came in for the save and gave up a 2 run homer to Jose Bautista. Buck Martinez said that Bautista had hit 2 home runs in that game, but corrected himself right away! He also did this a few games after with Travis Snider. This Buck Blunder got the second most contributions, besides the next one. View the video below.

Travis Thames

During the game vs. the Seattle Mariners on July 20th, 2011, Buck Martinez combined Travis Snider and Eric Thames to form, Travis Thames! This Buck Blunder netted 19 contributions and blew up my twitter feed (not as badly when Dan Johnson hit that home run to tie the game vs. the Yankees in game 162). Travis Thames did not go viral however and there is no video to back it up cause it wasn’t on a play of importance.


Which Buck Blunder below is the best Buck Blunder Of The Year?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Buck Blunders Post Season Recap


First and foremost, I would like to thank all the @buckblunders followers this year and all the contributions :) Without you guys and gals, there would be no www.buckblunders.com

So I had some time on the weekend to calculate the stats of all the Buck Blunders we found this year (note that there are probably more Buck Blunders that we did not pick up, especially the first 11 games, since I started this site late). I don’t have stats on how many times Buck did a specific blunder :( So without further ado, below you will find all the stats that I’ve gathered, because baseball is indeed a stats game :)

Total Buck Blunders Found


By Month

April: 51
May: 108
June: 127
July: 197
August: 178
September: 141

Top 10 Buck Blunder Contributors

(does not include my contributions)

  1. @jordangeville – 42
  2. @alittlehghas – 33
  3. @ShakeelSalamath – 33
  4. @AlanClough – 32
  5. @coolhead2010 – 30
  6. @GuzmansJhercurl – 26
  7. @BlueJayGal – 22
  8. @_skennedy – 22
  9. @s_poole420 – 21
  10. @LFri45 – 21

Total number of people who contributed at least once


Most Contributions for a single Buck Blunder

19 people contributed for the Buck Blunder on Game 98 vs. Seattle Mariners when Buck Martinez combined Travis Snider and Eric Thames to form Travis Thames.

Most blunders made by Buck Martinez in a single game

Buck Martinez made 15 record Buck Blunders on Game 88 vs. Boston Red Sox

ALDS Game 4: Texas Rangers vs. Tampa Bay Rays


Buck Blunder 1 – Buck Martinez called Casey Kotchman, Evan Longoria cause he thought Longoria was batting.

Buck Blunder 2 – Buck Martinez called Matt Harrison, Hariston.

Buck Blunder 3 – Kind of a Buck Blunder here as Buck Martinez said that umpires keep moving so they can get a good view of the play, but umpires are trained to be at the correct position right away! (Contributed by @andythequizzer)

ALDS Game 3: Rangers Vs. Rays


Buck Blunder 1 – Buck Martinez said that there would be a good lefty on lefty matchup with Colby Lewis and Johnny Damon… Lewis is a righty! (Contributed by @AlanClough)

Buck Blunder 2 – Buck Martinez combined two players… Jason Price! (John Jaso & David Price). (Contributed by @rolewiii)

Buck Blunder 3 – Buck Martinez said that Michael Young has seen Juan Cruz a lot! He had 6 career ABs before that AB! That is not a lot! (Contributed by @LacrosseBoss)

Buck Blunder 4 – Buck Martinez couldn’t pronounce Joel Peralta… He kept calling him Joll! (Contributed by @jordangeville)

ALDS Game 2: Texas Rangers vs. Tampa Bay Rays


Buck Blunder 1 – Buck Martinez said that Mike Napoli was acquired from the Angels. No Buck.. He was acquired from the Blue Jays via a trade from the Angels. (Contributed by @highcheese15)

Buck Blunder 2 – Buck Martinez called Matt Joyce, George! (Contributed by @AlanClough)

Buck Blunder 3 – Buck Martinez called Elvis Andrus, Elvish Androosh. (Contributed by @dustinparkes)

ALDS Game 1: Tampa Bay Rays vs. Texas Rangers


Just when I thought I could pack it up for the off season, Buck Martinez reappears on TBS. OMG! My twitter exploded with comments from the Buck Blunder fans out there, so because the fans asked for it, we are going to do Buck Blunders… Playoff Edition!

Buck Blunder 1 – Buck Martinez was talking about the defence for the Texas Rangers and he said, “Defensively behind the Tex…. I mean CJ Wilson.(Contributed by @jordangeville)

Buck Blunder 2 – Hey Buck, who’s Elderjwin Beltre???? (Contributed by @efraser3)

Buck Blunder 3 – Johnny Damon had a 2-1 count and he checked his swing to make it 3-1. Buck Martinez said the check swing saved him from a Strikeout.. But it was only 1 strike! (Contributed by @Shmu66)

Buck Blunder 4 – It’s so funny how Buck Martinez still thinks that John Lackey has only played 1 year with the Red Sox. It’s been his second year! (Contributed by @blandy12 and @MattWettlaufer)

Buck Blunder 5 – Buck Martinez said that Joaquin Benoit signed with the Texas Rangers… I mean Detroit Tigers for 1 year… He’s actually signed for 3. (Contributed by @AlanClough)

Buck Blunder 6 – Buck Martinez said Bartolo Colon signed a $900 Million dollar contract for 1 year! Man, I totally wish i had that! (Contributed by @SoberInThe500s, @AlanClough, @NikiFenix, @_skennedy, @CWardHenninger, @Carlosologist_7)

Buck Blunder 7 – Buck Martinez always says Concussion like “syndrome” (Contributed by @AlanClough)

Buck Blunder 8 – Buck Martinez said that Adam Kennedy hit 3 home runs in a playoff game and called him an “Elite” Home run hitter. Dude only has 77 career home runs in the regular season! (Contributed by @AlanClough and @Manu_P_Mishra)